The New York Yankees could be heading into one of their most pivotal offseasons in recent memory. Following a strong 2025 campaign, the team now faces the challenge of retaining several key contributors who played crucial roles in their success. With multiple players testing free agency, the Yankees’ roster could undergo major changes before the 2026 MLB season begins, potentially reshaping the club’s offensive core and outfield depth.At the center of this uncertainty is Cody Bellinger, who delivered a stellar all-around season but now stands as one of the most sought-after free agents on the market. Alongside him, Trent Grisham’s breakout year in the Bronx has also caught the attention of rival teams. If either or both depart, the Yankees will need to make bold moves to stay competitive – and that could lead them straight toward star outfielder Kyle Tucker, who is drawing early interest from several major contenders.
New York Yankees Facing Potential Outfield Shake-Up
The Yankees are at serious risk of losing multiple contributors from their 2025 roster, most notably star outfielder Cody Bellinger. The former MVP had a productive season, playing in 152 regular-season games while hitting .272/.334/.480 with 29 home runs and 98 RBIs. His consistency and power made him one of the most valuable pieces in the Yankees’ lineup.However, Bellinger isn’t the only name who could depart. Trent Grisham, who just had a career year in the Bronx, is also set to test the free-agent market. Grisham’s improved performance has made him an appealing target for several clubs, leaving the Yankees with potential gaps in their outfield.
New York Yankees’ 2025 Outfield Free Agents
Chicago Cubs Outfielder Kyle Tucker (Image via Getty)
| Player | 2025 Stats | Free Agent Status |
| Cody Bellinger | .272/.334/.480, 29 HR, 98 RBI | Free Agent |
| Trent Grisham | Career-best season | Free Agent |
If one or both of these players leave, the Yankees could find themselves scrambling for replacements in what promises to be a competitive free-agent market.
Kyle Tucker Emerges as Top Replacement Option
Fortunately for the Yankees, one of baseball’s top outfielders is also set to hit the market – Kyle Tucker. The Houston Astros star has established himself as one of the most reliable two-way players in the league, and his availability could reshape the Yankees’ offseason plans.According to The Athletic’s Doug Kezirian, with input from Borgata director of race and sports Thomas Gable, the Yankees are among the top contenders to land Tucker. Kezirian noted that “Cody Bellinger and Trent Grisham are both free agents, so if both of them go elsewhere, or even just Bellinger, the Yankees will definitely be in the running for Tucker.” (H/t: Sporting News)
Projected Odds to Sign Kyle Tucker
| Team | Odds |
| Los Angeles Dodgers | +250 |
| New York Yankees | +325 |
| Philadelphia Phillies | +575 |
| San Francisco Giants | +625 |
These odds are not available on any legal sportsbook, but they offer an interesting glimpse into how Tucker’s free agency could play out. The Yankees sit just behind the Dodgers as the most likely destination, which signals how seriously the organization might pursue him if Bellinger departs.
What’s Next for the Yankees
If the Yankees lose both Bellinger and Grisham, their need for a top-tier outfielder becomes urgent. Tucker, who brings power, defense, and playoff experience, would fit perfectly into the team’s long-term vision. However, competition will be fierce, and the front office will need to act aggressively to stay ahead of rival suitors like the Dodgers and Phillies.Also read: MLB trade rumors: Toronto Blue Jays predicted to dish in $50 million to build an aggressive play this offseasonThe offseason could mark a defining moment for the Yankees’ future. Whether they retain their current stars or pivot to new ones like Kyle Tucker, their decisions in the coming weeks will shape the club’s 2026 outlook and beyond.
